Hey,
Thanks for waiting for me to get back to you, I was putting together a bigger list for you to work from. I updated the page: http://www.neopets.com/~Micerica with more items and values from /~clara.
I might add more stuff to the list (which I'll highlight if I do) but once we've agreed to work from this list, I won't remove items without checking in with you.
Maybe you could keep a petpage of what you've got already, and then update what you've traded for as you go?
I was thinking middle ground values might be fairest, as you said. So where an item has a range of values, we go with the average? i.e. the value range for the wand is 100-200, and the average of the two is 150, so we value it at 150?
After that, the list is pretty obvious. I'd be happiest with as many of the items from highest priority as possible, and from second priority. The third priority list is only there for in case you can't find items of enough value from 1 and 2 (unlikely, but possible). If it gets to the point where you think you've exhausted items from priority 1 and 2 lists then we can chat about items from the third priority list.
Let me know your thoughts on the above - I've never done this before so I welcome your feedback.

Kimmi




Heads Up! You're about to leave Neopia!

You've clicked on a link that will take you outside of
Neopets.com. We do not control your destination's website,
so its rules, regulations, and Meepit defense systems will be
different! Are you sure you'd like to continue?



It is a journey
I must face...alone.
*dramatic music*
I want to stay on Neopets,
where the dangers of
Meepit invasion
are taken seriously.
Heads Up! You're about to leave Neopia!

You've clicked on a link that will take you outside of
Neopets.com. We do not control your destination's website,
so its rules, regulations, and Meepit defense systems will be
different! Are you sure you'd like to continue?



It is a journey
I must face...alone.
*dramatic music*
I want to stay on Neopets,
where the dangers of
Meepit invasion
are taken seriously.
Heads Up! You're about to leave Neopia!

You've clicked on a link that will take you outside of
Neopets.com. We do not control your destination's website,
so its rules, regulations, and Meepit defense systems will be
different! Are you sure you'd like to continue?



It is a journey
I must face...alone.
*dramatic music*
I want to stay on Neopets,
where the dangers of
Meepit invasion
are taken seriously.
/help/bumper/headers/log-in-to-facebook

NEOPETS, characters, logos, names and all related indicia
are trademarks of Neopets, Inc., © 1999-2017.
® denotes Reg. US Pat. & TM Office. All rights reserved.

PRIVACY POLICY | Safety Tips | Contact Us | About Us | Press Kit
Use of this site signifies your acceptance of the Terms and Conditions