I'll tell you 3 things I like about your fonts and 3 things I don't. Then I'll give it a score out of 100 and tell you the mistakes you made.

First impression:
When I first see your font, what do I think? Easy to read? Not too complex?
?/10

Color:
Do the colors match with your avatar? Are they too bright or too light?
?/10

Text/Picture:
Is the siggy nice? Does the picture look like what its supposed to be?
?/10

Cohesion with avatar:
Does the font match the avatar, both in colors and in text/pic?
?/10

Overall Quality:
How does it look overall? Pretty self-explanatory.
?/10

I'll add up the points and then double them to get your score out of 100.

First impression:
The palm tree is very well executed as soon as you look at it. Even if you stare for a while, it's still very pretty.
9/10

Color:
The colors match perfectly, but the blue looks a little bit out of place...I suggest using a darker sand color for the bottom text.
8/10

Text/Picture:
It's amazing :) I don't like the font face at the bottom though...it just didn't fit with the palm tree.
8/10

Cohesion with avatar:
The idea matches perfectly with the idea of the avatar.
10/10

Overall Quality:
Your font is great. All of your fonts are : ) Fantastic job !
9/10

You got an 88/100! You can pick up your award here!

First impression:
I love the sandcastle :* It's just so well planned. But the text at the bottom is hard to read, I suggest making it darker.
8/10

Color:
They match well, but it would be cool if you used more colors. Like instead of black for the neoHTML you could use green or blue.
8/10

Text/Picture:
It's just amazing : ) But I did take off a point for the hard to read text.
9/10

Cohesion with avatar:
The idea matches perfectly with the idea of the avatar.
10/10

Overall Quality:
Your font is just amazing, and if you tweak it just a little bit it will be super amazing : ) Awesome job !
9/10

You got an 88/100! You can pick up your award here!