Shattered Crystals

First Impression: 29 out of 30.
This is certainly going to be a pleasant review. =) Your site is beautiful. Dark - but still beautiful. Everything is set in its own place and organized which by now everyone knows I love that. The only thing that made me dock a point off is something with the layout. I'll explain why in the layout section. For the most part moving from page to page is easy and fun. I have IE and it did take a bit to load the banner, but the results were great. It was worth the extra 15 second wait.
Theme Consistency: 12 out of 10.
Your theme is a graphics maker and you didn't stray away from that at all. You also have a certain style of graphics I noticed and you never left it. You even stated that you wouldn't do a specific kind(Disney Channel Stars etc.). Letting your "customers" know these things are really useful to them. You like doing anime and video game graphics so that's what you do. It's that simple. And I can tell you really love it, that's worth a couple extra points.
Layout: 29 out of 30.
Okay, we're finally to this section. I can let all my hot air out about this layout. =) The only thing I didn't like was how the end of the last table was the end of the page. That really leaves no room to roam. I must say, as ridiculous as this sounds, I am claustrophobic and that browser page really scares me. I know it sounds crazy, stop laughing! That page really does make me feel box in, like I have no more space. I love to have room to scroll and read one thing within my screen at a time. I'm not saying you should have a mile of empty page down there but give your readers some room. They'll feel safe, haha. (How dumb did that whole section sound?)
Colors: 10 out of 10.
Your colors stay the same through the whole site and go well with the content. A dark site goes well with darker kinds of content. If you were making rainbow colored muffin faeries then you'd probably want to change it... for future references...
Content: 21 out of 20.
Your content is lovely. Just lovely. It was a pleasure to go through and look at it. My favorite is the FMA "Miniskirts!" icon. Best episode ever. =) That really made me laugh. It's great how you tell your readers about the topic your graphics are on. I found that very useful because I had no idea what the whole "Warriors" hype was, so after I read it I understood it a lot more than I did before. I can find no misspelled words after looking.
Overall Score and Comments: 101 out of 100.
Well, there is no award for over 100, but I'm sure the 100 will be fine for you. =) I've enjoyed this review and wish you luck with your page. Thanks for requesting a review!

Mistlickles (Closed)

First Impression: 20 out of 30.

Tales of the Pets

First Impression: 17 out of 30.
The background is warm and friendly. But the other colors do not match at all. I know you might be going for the mismatched cute look, which would be a great idea but try and find darker colors instead of NEON-IN-YOUR-FACE-OMG cyan/blue/green etc. =) The layout is nice but try and find a more organized one. Everything is all out everywhere. Try changing the font also. It's very plain. Directories are supposed to be impressive and strong, not so-so and weak. Theme Consistency: 10 out of 10. Your theme is carried out throughout your page. Your directory is a directory. Exactly what it is supposed to be. =)
Layout: 18 out of 30.
You have a lot of content that you need to put on your page and you need the layout space for it! Try to find a more organized layout with a lot of extra room to put your info! That way it will look like a true directory.
Colors: 4 out of 10.
As I explained earlier the colros are way bright even for that mismatched theme. Try and find darker colors that feel warmer and mix together.
Content: 15 out of 20.
Your content is overloaded onto your page! You need more room as I've said. You have a lot of content to put since youre a directory so it needs to spread out. The section headers could be images or outlined with a box. They need to stand out other than being big. Your links at the top need to be bigger. I couldnt even tell they were there. =) Your pet navigation could be more organized, but I don't have any tips
Overall Score and Comments: 64 out of 100.
You're off to a good start! Directories take a lot of work and focus. Stay with it though and you'll come out on top!

First Impression: 19 out of 30.
When I first saw Midnight Buttons the main factor that appealed to me was the organization of it. Everything was laid out neatly, I love that about sites. The one thing I noticed was the colors of the section bars thoguh since they stand out so much. The second blue color doesn't match. The buttons were of a lower quality not in the design but in the colors which I will explain how to fix this later on. Some things are out of place though...
Theme Consistency: 5 out of 10.
Your theme is obviously "Midnight" and "buttons". That was easy to figure out. =) But you never mention midnight or night or anything like that on your page. You need to add more things relating to the theme, like add a crescent moon under the "Midnight Buttons" section. And align it to the left and have a word wrap on it so your text will go beside it. Little things like that make the viewer pleased and want to come back. (I can't provide a link to a petpage that can help you with this because I am on another computer for the moment, I'm sorry, but try some of the help links below or ask on the Help Board!)
Layout: 26 out of 30.
Your layout is organized into sections and I love that, but some of them need to be switched around. Your updates should be below your introduction section so your viewers instantly see what your new updates are. But the rest is in the correct and proper order.
Colors: 4 of 10.
Your background color is fine, but the section colors are off from your banner. Unless you change your banner to have those colors they're not going to work. To find more colors it would be useful to look at an html color chart which you can easily search for on any search engine and find. Soem darker blues would work just fine.
Content: 11 out of 20.
One thing I highly recomend is saving your buttons under the .png file. I'm going to guess you use MS Paint. Well, when you go to the usually place and press save the box comes up, name the button, the select from the drop down list PNG (.png). Then save them as that file. They will look so much better and cleaner. Also, your banner is supposed to catch the attention of the viewer, and it is slightly bland. I'd recomend downloading some new fonts to your computer. It's not that hard. If you search How to download fonts to my computer on any search engine there should be some guides to help you. I use the site Dafont. Search Dafont also and it will be one of the first ones. It's a site to download free fonts to your computer and they are really nice ones. =) It's just like usual, you select it from the font dropdown menu in paint and start typing away. You can do so much with them, like if you have a real pretty cursive font you can make a big, size 14 G and have the pretty cursive lines on the edge of the button so it just looks like curved lines coming out. It really looks nice if you do it right, trust me. =)
Overall Score and Comments: 65 out of 100.
Well this review was full of great information(atleast I hope so!). You don't quite qualify for an award, but after you've taken some of my adive to heart just neomail me and I'll do another review! I'm sure it'll turn out great next time! Keep updating! You've got good ideas and good creativity!