First Look- 10/10 When I first look at the site, what do I see? Is there a nice, pretty banner? The First Look is important because you can see what catchs your eye when you look at the site.
Introduction- 10/10 What did you write for the Introduction? Do you have one at all? Is it plain like just saying "Welcome to my site."?
Updates- 5/5 People might be thinking, why is updating important? It is important because visitors know you've been on lately so they know if they should request a review or buttons or whatever kind of site you have.
Grammer/Spelling- 10/10 If your site is full of spelling mistakes, who would understand what you are saying?
Orginization- 20/20 Does your site have a navigation, is it neat and tidy?
Content- 20/20 Do your buttons look nice, have you listed a lot of people, have you reviewed a lot of people?
Link Back- 5/5 Are your link backs all made by you? All made by someone else?
Originality- 20/20 Is it like a normal site? Does it have any unique stuff?

Soroptimist Directory

First Look- 10/10 The layout is very neat and tidy and the banner is nice. I like the whole "pirate" theme. It fits everything in the site.
Introduction- 9/10 I love the introduction, it sounds like your on a real boat. The only thing I don't like is that it's squished up in such a tiny box.
Updates- 5/5 I love how it says "Crow's Nest" on the top. So Unique! You update nearly every day, and I love the "I'm Currently Online_ button, so unique!
Grammer/Spelling- 10/10 No problem! Nice job!
Originization- 20/20 Nice and orginized, the navigation helps a lot!
Content- 20/20 Soroptimist is one of the best directories out there! You listed tons of sites! Wow!
Link Back- 4/5 I only see 2 buttons made by you, but you got tons of gift buttons! Maybe you should add a OPEN/CLOSED for gift buttons!
Originality- 20/20 The "Online_" buttons and all the other "Neomail" buttons are very unique! Also love the site name!

Overall Score- 99/100 Congrats!