Navigation

Introduction Rules Grading Scale Tips for Success Apply Reviews

Reviewed Sites

Total: 7
Emily's Buttons A. Mercury's Music Asparagus Anon. Bella's Goodies Graphic Sites: ACG Colors of the Wind Secret Observer Inu-Graphics Connie's Fake Avs.
Pre-June '09 reviews
located here.

Waiting List

1. None
2. None
3. None
4. None
5. None

Link Back?

88 x 31:

88 x 31:
Amy's Button Basket


88 x 31:
Dark Light

Affiliates

Neomail me to become an affie.

Listed At


Credit

Layout v.4 by
Kitty.

Main image by
Akira Himekawa.

Browser Compatibility:


Counter
Started 11.30.08

Site started
21.7.08

Old reviews (July '08 - May '09) relocated because of a coding problem on 20.6.09.
Relocation.

Introduction

Hello guest, and welcome to Siren's Song Reviews! My name is Kitty, and I'll be reviewing your sites today.

Why a siren, you ask? Sirens have been known in myth and legend for centuries for singing sailors to their deaths. Their song is so irresistible that the men steer their boats towards the sound, and crash on the jagged island that the sirens call their home. Therefore, a siren's song draws people in, and makes them stay.

My siren has called you here, to show you these sites. These sites have been thoroughly reviewed, and the best will be rewarded. Why not submit your site, let the siren do the reviewing, and see who comes to your site?

Back to Top

IMPORTANT!

As of November 14, 2009, I cleared the waiting list. Most of the sites had been on hiatus since August, which, I believe, was when I last had contact with the Neopets world. If you want to get back on the list, please reapply and I'll get to you as soon as possible, I promise!

Rules

1. I will take as long as I want to review your petpage, so be patient. I'll neomail you when done. Remember that I have a life off of Neopets, so don't bug me about your review!

2. There can only be five people at a time on the waiting list. When the waiting list is full, I will close reviews. When there is a spot open, the first person to send in their form will be added in the empty spot.

3. You must link back to me before, during, and after a review. If you do not, you will be noted as a rule-breaker forever (or at least until you put my button up) on my site.

4. I do not review screenie petpages, Site of the Month pages, Off-Site Pages, "Fanclub" sites, guild pages (or the guild itself), or other Review sites. Those are not only difficult to review fairly, but are also a waste of my time & yours.

5. You may resubmit your petpage, but there must be a maximum time of 2-4 weeks between submissions. I only do two re-reviews per site. So, that's a maximum of three reviews for your site.

Back to Top

Grading Scale

I will base your review on a few different things. Please read the scale below carefully, so there are no surprises.

**Specify Browser Choice:**
Choose the browser that you want me to review it in, or I will review it in my default browser (FireFox).
First glance: {How does your site look when I first glance at it? Is it neat? Does it look awesome? Does the layout invite me to stay? Is the layout premade or did you create it? Or is it a custom layout?} --/10 points

Spelling: {Do you use chatspeak? Did you spell everything correctly?} -/5 points

Grammar: {Do you capitalize things? Is every sentence grammatically correct?} -/5 points

Neatness: {Can I find everything correctly? Is the layout nicely made, or is it sloppy? Is there in-site navigation? How about the links? Are they all working correctly?} --/10 points

Colors: {Do all of your colors fit together? Do they match your layout? Can I read everything?} --/10 points

Music: {Do you have music? Does it fit your site's theme? Is it annoying? Does it make me want to shut out the page as soon as I come to it?} -/5 points

Age of site: {Do you have a counter? Are there plenty of graphics, considering how long you've been open? How many updates do you have, and do they corrospond to your opening date?} --/10 points

Quality: {Is everything just thrown together randomly, without any thought as to how it might look, or is everything just beautiful? How does it all fit together? Are the graphics crisp and clear, or are they blurry and sloppy? How are your link-back buttons?} {Omitted for directories!} --/10 points

Updated list: {How long have you been open, and do your updates corrospond to this date? How often do you update? What do you update on?} --/10 points

Extras: {Do all of your links work correctly? Are any images broken, dead, etc.? What makes your site stand out from the others of its kind?} -/5 points

Other problems: {Brief overview of what I mentioned before, plus some other things that I saw. How well did you hide your mistakes, little one?} *No Points deducted*

Overall Score: {How well did you do? Did you do good? *add parting comments*} --/80 points overall
I believe that my review style is non-prejudiced, however, considering that I am human, I sometimes make mistakes. In the "Other Problems" section, I will state things that I personally do not like in your site. Other than that, everything you see in the review will be non-prejudiced.

Back to Top

Tips for Success

I have reviewed a lot of sites (86 at last count), and I see the same mistakes being made over and over and over again. It gets very tiring. So I have compiled a little list of things you may want to know before I review your site.

1. Never, ever use chatspeak. Not only does it turn people off, it makes it hard for the reviewers to read your page. It also lowers your score considerably.

2. Make sure you update your page often and have a counter on your page. Boingdragon[dot]com is a good place to get a counter. You can even customize it!

3. If you own a graphic site and you don't know how to get started, please try using my friend Siddey's site:
She'll teach you the intricacies of site ownership.

Back to Top

Application

So, you've read the rules, and you still want the siren to review you? Very well. Fill out the form below completely and carefully, then neomail it to me.

Reviews are currently: open! Apply now!
Back to Top

Reviews

These are the people who the Siren has reviewed. Look through them. The best sites have been identified, and have been awarded.

**Notice**
All old reviews (before June 2009) have been moved here. There was some sort of coding problem, but I solved it by moving old reviews. Sorry for any inconvenience.

Emmy's Buttons


Reviewed on July 18, 2009
Reviewed in Internet Explorer
First Glance: 8/10. The main page is really...boring. Sure, the background's pretty cool, and the CSS is awesome, but you should have a banner or something. How do I know what the site is? All I see is "Hey, guest! I'm Emmy and this is my button request page!"
Why not say, "Hey, guest! Welcome to Emmy's Buttons!" or something like that, since you don't have a banner? How do we (the visitors) know what your site is named?

I know your image host crashed, but that was a week ago. When my image host crashed (I lost EVERYTHING - all of my graphics, banners, layouts, etc.), I got everything back up within three days (that's over 500 images - restored), except my GIMP Tutorial, which is difficult to do. I am still working on that.
Get your banner up as soon as possible!

If you look at your sidebar, it looks different than your main content boxes. Try to make them uniform.

Spelling 5/5. The only thing that I saw (and didn't bother taking points off for, since it's just a small thing) was that you put a hyphen in "Neomail." There's no hyphen (a hyphen is a dash - ) in the word.

Grammar: 2/5. While your spelling is great, your grammar is not that good.... I'll put your words in italics, and put the corrected sentence underneath it in (parentheses).

Oh and neomail me for questions, comments, or anything else.
(Oh, and neomail me your questions, comments, or anything else.)

Oh and one more thing. Could you spare a vote?
(Oh, and one more thing: could you spare a vote?)

Well first things first. THE STEPS!
(Well, first things first: THE STEPS!)

(I know, very cheesy)
(I know, very cheesy.)

Copy the form under the next header and neomail with the info filled in.
(Copy the form under the next header and neomail me with the info filled in.)

Send the form to me, I'll make your button and then neo-mail you when it's done.
(Send the form to me, I'll make your button, and then I'll neomail you when it's done.)

Okay, no one has asked me questions yet, so I made up my own.
(Okay, since nobody has asked me any questions yet, I made up my own.)

I'd love to. But it's but I'm really lazy, and it's probably hard via neo-.
(I'd love to, but I'm really lazy, and it's probably hard to teach you via neomail.)

Neatness: 9/10. Everything seems to be in its proper place, although I'm a little confused as to why you're in your affiliates section. You can't be an affiliate with yourself! Most people don't like having their button put in marquees, either...you might want to rethink that.

Colors: 8/10. The black background is incredibly pretty, but it doesn't match the pink, white, and yellow color scheme you have. Either change the yellow to gray, or change the background to something that matches better.

Music: 5/5. Great job on keeping your page music-free!

Age of Site: 6/10. Your site has been up for two months. That's great. What's not great, however, is that you don't have a counter (to keep track of how many people visit your page). To get a free one that works on Neopets, search for Boingdragon Counters on the search engine of your choice.

You should probably have a section where you display buttons that you have made in the past - like a portfolio of your work. Many button sites have that - like Greyscaled Buttons. That would keep a record of what you've done (so if someone ever lost a button, they could come back and get it again), and it would tell reviewers and other requesters what you can do.

Quality: 8/10. By looking at your buttons (and the one smiley banner), it doesn't look like you use a pixel font on your buttons. The font always looks a little squished. The font on the banner looks like it's fuzzy on the sides. But the images look very nice - you've done a good job of bringing them down to size.

Updated List: 5/10. There are several big gaps in your updates. I realize that you left for camp for a few weeks, but for a month and a half (between the day you started the site and June 23), you don't update at all. Updates keep your people updated (hence the name) - if you don't update your site (even with pointless ones, just to tell the public that you're still alive!), people may not request anything.
Oh, she hasn't updated for a month or so. She must not get on Neopets anymore."

Extras: 1/5. You really don't offer anything else besides your normal, cut-and-dried button request site. Sure, you have a FAQ section, but that's about it. Do something to interact with your public! Make a portfolio of old buttons you've made. Make a few more link-back buttons! There are several things you can do to make your site more interesting - try something new!

Other Problems: Remember, when you're using the a href= code, you have to put the (/a) at the end of it! (Replace the parentheses with the carrot-y brackets.)

Overall Score: 57/80. That's a 72%. Congratulations! That's not bad for your first review!! Just fix a few things on your site (the colors and your updates, most importantly), and you'll have a very nice site! Keep going!
Back to Top

A. Mercury's Music


Reviewed on July 11, 2009
Reviewed in Internet Explorer
First Glance: 7/10. It looks very plain. There's nothing that says, "Hey! Look at me!" Plus, the third column is lower than the rest of them. I would suggest getting a banner (if you want one; there are a lot of sites out there that make really good quality banners), and figuring out why the last column is lower than the rest.

Spelling 5/5. I couldn't find any spelling mistakes - that's great!

Grammar: 3/5. I found a few grammatical mistakes. I'm going to put your words in italics, and then I'll put the corrected statement underneath them in (parentheses).

If you see a song that doesn't work neomail me HERE and let me know and I'll find a code that works or just take it off of my site.
(If you see a song that doesn't work, neomail me HERE and let me know. I'll find a code that works, or just take it off of my site.)

And also I've made my decision to make this a music page for ONLY classic rock songs.
(I've also decided to make this a music page for ONLY class rock songs.)

Freddie, here, is under REAL legal copyrights,(Along with all my other Blockian characters) and so if you steal him, you'd end up in DEEP trouble. So please don't.
(Freddie here is under REAL legal copyrights (along with all of my other Blockian characters), so if you steal him, you'll end up in DEEP trouble. Please don't.)

PLEASE fill out the request form, if you want to request a song. If you don't I will not do the request.
(PLEASE fill out the request form if you want to request a song. If you don't, I will not do the request.)

I ONLY do requests of classic rock songs or any other song that's from the 80's or earlier (such as the 1970's or 60's ect.) Any other request will be ignored so please keep this in mind.
(I ONLY do requests of classic rock songs or any other songs that are from the 80's or earlier (such as the 1970's, 1960's, etc.). Any other requests will be ignored, so please keep this in mind.)

Neatness: 8/10. Your page is organized rather neatly (music pages have to be), but there are a few things out of place. Your links/affiliates should be above your reviews (like you have in your navigation). If you're not going to put them above the reviews, switch around the navigation links so that "reviews" is before "links." You should also not put anybody who reviewed you in your "affiliates" section unless you asked to be affiliates with them (or vice versa). The navigation for the music codes should be above the description of Freddie, and the rules probably should, too.

Colors: 7/10. Since you didn't make the layout, but edited it, I can't give you full points here. You did add an extra column & take away the navigation links on the side (if I figured out the premade that you used correctly), but the side column that you added is a little wonky (it's lower than the rest). The colors do seem to be great for a site named Mercury's Music, though, so you do get a few extra points.

Music: 5/5. Great! Even though you're a music codes site, you don't have to have music on the page, and you don't! Music on petpages is incredibly annoying....

Age of Site: 5/10. Unfortunately, I can only give you half credit for this category. Your site started almost two years ago, but you have only three updates, and you started your counter six days ago. You should have started those things when you started your site, you know...it would have made things much easier. You do have a lot of music codes (but nothing from the Eagles? Gasp!), but that's only half the site. Without updates, nobody will know when you've added new music codes.

Quality: **Not applicable for directories or music code sites. Your score will be out of 70.**

Updated List: 3/10. Updates are the life-blood of your site; without them, people won't know when you've updated your site (thus the name "updates"). Be sure to update often.

Extras: 4/5. I've never seen another character like Freddie.

Other Problems: You do know that music codes are, technically, copyright infringement, right? You're not paying the artist for their music, and you're redistributing the codes without permission? You're giving away the music for free. Yes, they can't put the music on their iPod or mp3 player,, but it's still copyright infringement. But with so many of these sites out there, I doubt anybody will ever get sued for it.

Overall Score: 47/70. That's a 67%. Not too bad, actually, considering that most of the other music code sites I have reviewed received less than 50%. Keep working on your site - you have great potential ^.^
Back to Top

Asparagus Anonymous


Reviewed on July 6, 2009
Reviewed in Mozilla FireFox
First Glance: 9/10. Ha ha! Adam! Yay! Asparagus, asparagus, asparagus...Wow, that's fun to say! This looks like a fun site (and the banner makes it uber-awesome!), but there's a small bit of a space between the top of the table & the first header. To get rid of that, find the header number (h1, I think it is) in between the style tags, and add this:
into the coding. That should get rid of that space. If it doesn't....I don't know what will.

Spelling 2/5. In several occasions you misspell "asparagus" (how could you?!), and you misspell "definitely" as well.

Grammar: 0/5. Wow - your grammar is atrocious! I apologize, but, really - even though you're updating, you don't have to abandon all the rules of grammar! I can count at least five mistakes in the July 6 update alone. Be sure to make every sentence grammatically correct, even if they're in your updates and you don't think it's important to use complete sentences, do it. People will be more likely to come to a site when everything is spelled correctly and it's written in proper English.

Now, updates aside (I'm not going to go through the updates; that would take more patience than I have, I'm afraid), most of your other sentences have something wrong with them as well. Your words will be in italics, and the corrections will be underneath them in (parentheses). Let's get started, shall we?

Have you found yourself thinking about asparagus morning, noon, and night? Going into a cold sweat when theres no asparagus left?
(Have you found yourself thinking about asparagus morning, noon, and night, going into a cold sweat when there's no asparagus left?)

If yes is the answer you've come to the right place.
(If yes is the answer, then you've come to the right place.)

This is Asparagus Anonymous help for all you asparagus addicts out there!
(This is Asparagus Anonymous, help for all you asparagus addicts out there!)

Are you a self confessed AA?
(Are you a self-confessed AA?)

I couldn't go a day without Asparagus but with a lot of willpower I overcame it and thats why I started this site to help other people like me
(I couldn't go a day without asparagus, but with a lot of willpower I overcame it. That's why I started this site - to help other people like me.)

A question you ask yourself repeatedly? I know I do! Well with 50 items and even a a pet dedicated to the green piece of strange vegatable its easy to see why people can get addicted?
(Do you ask yourself this question repeatedly? I know I do! Well, with 50 items and even a pet dedicated to this green vegetable, it's easy to see why people can get addicted!)

Just the one I'm rather disappointed.......
(There's only one. I'm rather disappointed...)

One day my friend one day........
(One day, my friend, one day...)

Could Asparagus World be true this article seems to think so.
(Could Asparagus World exist? This article seems to think so.)

Take one day at a time, don't let yourself waste stupid amounts of NP on Asparagus.
(Take it one day at a time. Don't let yourself waste incredible amounts of NP on asparagus!)

2.Set yourself targets.
(What on earth is this supposed to mean?)

Try not to freak out at everything green, in fact remove anything green from around you to make sure you don't go crazy.
(Try not to freak out at everything green. In fact, remove anything that is green from around your person to make sure you won't go crazy.)

Low in calories less than 4 calories per stick!
(Low in calories - less than four calories per stick!)

Its Adams favourite food.
(It's Adam's favorite food.)

Theres such thing as white asparagus
(There is such a thing as white asparagus.)

If ridges form on your asparagus thats a sign of age, soaking in ice water will get them right as rain again (AAs please DO NOT eat out of date asparagus it won't be pretty).
(If ridges form on your asparagus, that's a sign of age. Soaking it in ice water will get them right as rain again (AAs, please DO NOT eat out-of-date asparagus; it won't be pretty!).)

Well just incase you cannot fight the urge.........
(Well, just in case you cannot fight the urge...)

Well if you couldn't help yourself you loved asparagus soo much you just had to turn one of your pets into one heres a list of those strange asparagus themed pets.
(Well, if you just couldn't help yourself - you loved asparagus so much you just had to turn one of your pets into one - here's a list of asparagus-themed pets.)

Neatness: 10/10. Everything is organized very nicely. Great job!

Colors: 8/10. So...much...green! But in this case, green is good!

Music: 5/5. Great job. Although, I can't think of what sort of music "asparagus" brings to mind...it would probably be rocking!

Age of Site: 8/10. Very good! Although you said in your neomail you had been open for a week and a half...your updates only start at July 1. What happened to those updates?

Quality: ** Not applicable to your review. Your grade will be out of seventy. **

Updated List: 8/10. Several updates I couldn't make heads or tails of (I blame the grammar), but you seem to update very often. There's a problem, though - you said in your neomail you had been open for a week and a half...your updates only start at July 1. What happened to those updates? Otherwise, keep working on the grammar.

Extras: 4/5. I have never seen a site like this before. You are truly one-of-a-kind.

Other Problems: None that I can think of.

Overall Score: 54/70. That's a 77%. Congratulations! Certainly not bad for your first review from me (and the highest one I've had next to Siddey's Graphic Sites Guide, after the cleanout)! Keep working on your site (most certainly the grammar).
Back to Top

Bella's Goodies


Reviewed on July 5, 2009
Reviewed in Internet Explorer
First Glance: 3/10. Well, it's really, really boring, I'll give you that. A plain background (with a funky wide line down the middle) doesn't help the layout any. Jazz it up with a banner or something (this is a GRAPHICS site, right?).

Spelling 5/5. I didn't find any spelling mistakes.

Grammar: 0/5. Wow - you're a grammatical mess, aren't you? Here's what I'm going to do - your words will be in italics; my corrections will be in (parentheses) underneath yours. Ready? Let's go.

This site was opened on June 21,2009.This is a backgrounds,icons,and button base site. You can also request a button. Browse and enjoy!
(This site was opened on June 21, 2009, as a backgrounds, icons, and button bases site. You can also request a button. Browse and enjoy!)

6/28/09:Added a navigation,reviews,pick-up,and helpful advice section.
(6/28/09: Added navigation, reviews, pick-ups, and helpful advice sections.)

6/29/09:Added 2 new icons.
(6/29/09: Added two new icons.)

6/30/09:Added 2 buttons,2 backgrounds,2 button bases,and 1 icon. I also did my first request!
(6/30/09: Added two new buttons, two backgrounds, two button bases, and one icon. I also did my first request!)

7/1/09:I deleted the 1st 2 updates. I'll do that every few weeks so that people don't need to scroll down too much to see the newest update. Also,I am editing 2 of the buttons. I also got a new counter.
(7/1/09: I deleted the first two updates. I'll do that every few weeks so people don't need to scroll down too much to see the newest updates. Also, I am editing two of the buttons, and I got a new counter.)

7/2/09:Added a new patterned icon. I also did two 50x50 icons. I got a review from Appraisals. Let's just it wasn't the best. Editing,here I come! I also added my first affie.
(7/2/09: Added a new patterned icon. I also made two 50x50 icons. I received a review from Appraisals. Let's just say it wasn't the best in the world. Editing, here I come! I added my first affie.)

From the top,ladies!
(From the top, ladies!)

If you requested something,get here. Everybody can take something from here,even if they didn't request it.
(If you requested something, pick it up here. Everybody can take something from here, even if they didn't request it.)

Neatness: 5/10. While everything is semi-easy to find, there are a lot of things you can do to your site in order to make it better. First of all, don't put your affiliates (or affiliate, in this case) in a marquee. Most people don't appreciate being shoved into a marquee so that visitors only see one site at a time (and their site may be skipped over). Secondly, put your listings on the same side as your affiliates & reviewers (it only makes sense; put them above the reviewers but below the affiliates). Thirdly, put that "helpful advice" section in the backgrounds section - it makes more sense that way. Fourthly (is that a word? Well, I'm making it one), put your request forms in the request section! And fifthly (my word! Leave it alone!), make sure you link your icons & banners back to your page within the codes. Otherwise, nobody will remember to give you credit.

Colors: 5/10. I can't really give you any credit for this section, really. You didn't make the layout, you didn't edit anything (except for the background, I believe. Cass wouldn't make anything like that), and you left everything the same. Although the lime-green headers (like for "credits" and "views") are a bit too much.

Music: 10/10. Great! No music. I think that's really the only thing you have going for your site.

Age of Site: 3/10. You don't have many updates (you deleted your first two updates? How could you?), and your graphics are...lacking. You started your counter a whole ten days after you started your site (for shame!), and you don't have many hits, nor are you listed on many directories. Get your site out there! If you want more hits, you need to advertise more (although, considering the quality of your "graphics," you may not get many more hits).

Quality: 1/10. They're mediocre at the best (and complete garbage at the worst). While there are people who can make amazing graphics in MS Paint, I'm afraid to say that you aren't one of them (you asked for my honest opinion when you signed up for a review). Not only are your graphics blurry, but they sometimes have stray pixels (white or otherwise) around them.

Your "blank icons" (the 150 x 150 ones) I seriously doubt anybody will want to use.

The button bases look like anything my cat can make (yes, I've left MS Paint open while I got a sandwich, and my cat walked over the keyboard). Plus, two of them look like you just took a picture from Google & squished it so it would fit the 88 x 31 pixel requirements. That is not how you make a button base. You find interesting segments of images, and make the base fit the image, not the other way around.

Your link-back buttons are of amateur quality as well. There are several good button tutorials out there (the best being Ashyaruu's Button Tutorial), which will teach you how to make amazing buttons (it'll also help with button bases).

The backgrounds are pretty bad, too. There are a few good ones, however...
That's the best one you have - and it's still amateur. Do you know why? *points to gray pixels around faces*

These two icons, however, look really bad:
They're just images pasted onto a paint document, with words plastered above them. That's NOT an icon.

Your icons... (50x50), well, they have problems too. The most prominent being you're not using a pixel font.
^ This is a semi-good one. ^
^ This is a no-no. ^
You should try not to put the text OVER the image itself (the main focus of your icon). Your icons should also be 100 x 100 pixels instead of any other sizes. You should make the images link back to you as well.

Since I can't think of anything else to say about your graphics, remember this:
Save your images as .pngs.

Updated List: 5/10. Okay, let's get this out of the way:
NEVER, EVER DELETE YOUR UPDATES!
You have to put the newest updates at the TOP of your page (that solves the "so much scrolling!" problem, you see), and you should put them in a scrollbox (again, with the newest updates at the top):
I have even provided a code for a updates box for you. Use it to your advantage.

Other Problems: Too many to count. Look back over the review. I don't feel like listing everything again.

Overall Score: 37/80. That's about a 45%. Not bad for your first review from me (considering the state of your site). You have a LOT of work to do, I'll give you that, and it's mostly going to be uphill from here. But if you fight your way to the top, you're going to have a hard time falling down a rung. Keep going.
Back to Top

Graphic Sites: A Complete Guide


Reviewed on June 23, 2009
Reviewed in Mozilla FireFox
First Glance: 9/10. While the site layout is simply amazing (like all of your layouts, Siddey), it just doesn't look, to me, like a "guide" layout. The bird doesn't look right. Otherwise, it looks amazing. Your coding skills are beyond comprehension. Only Chuck Norris can comment on your CSS skills.

Spelling 3/5. Not only do you misspell the word "affiliates" multiple times (as affilates), but when you mention the different browsers one can use (Chrome, FireFox, Explorer, Safari, Opera), you misspell the word "browsers" as "browers." And in your grading scale (for your graphic site reviews), you misspell "Organization!" In the "Kupo's Graphics" review, there's a weird word; I can't tell what it's supposed to be. What is "mdate" supposed to mean? Update?

Grammar: 2/5. Siddey, Siddey, Siddey! You need to work on your grammar, I'm afraid. I shall post a sentence in italics; that is the original sentence. The sentence underneath it in (parentheses) is the corrected sentence. Study hard, Siddey-san!

At this magnificent resource I, Siddey, will teach you how to make a spectacular graphic site!
(At this magnificent resource, I, Siddey, will teach you how to make a spectacular graphic site!)

So let's get going, I bet you can't wait!
(So let's get going; I bet you can't wait!)

Now you just want to get started right?
(Now you just want to get started, right?)

First of all, you are probably wondering why in Neopia is this site here. It is here because, many people have graphic sites, but that doesn't mean they are top-quality.
(First of all, you are probably wondering why in Neopia this site is here. It is here because many people have graphic sites, but that doesn't mean they are top-quality.)

Secondly, you might want to know, who am I to talk?
(Secondly, who am I to talk?)

Before you decide on a name, make a layout, or anything you have to decide what type of graphic site best suits you.
(Before you decide on a name, make a layout, or anything, you have to decide what type of graphic site best suits you.)

Those are just a few of the ones that I found in the first two sections. I'm not going to go over all of the little details (commas, semicolons, etc.) but you should copy & paste everything into Microsoft Word, and use the spell check feature. It will help you a lot!

Neatness: 9/10. *glares* I was all set to give you a low score in this category, too! One button was an 'x-d' out box, so I refreshed the page. Lo and behold, you had updated the page since I opened it. So all the dead links I was about to rat on disappeared and were replaced! Anyways... One of your updates say that you have deleted Siddey's Site Pack. Yes, that's true - in a sense. But you still have the text area up with all the information in it! You should replace that with the Certification Application, and put a text area containing the button's information underneath the button! And I know that Tina of Dark Light Graphics has applied to you! She's mentioned it several times to me (being in her guild as I am). Hop to it, Siddey!

Colors: 10/10. Everything matches really well! Great job.

Music: 10/10. Woo! Go Siddey, go Siddey! *dances to a Chick-Fil-A commercial* No music + Kitty = Awesomesauce.

Age of Site: 9/10. Having been open for four months, I would have expected more than 900 hits on your counter. You have an awesome site - how come people aren't coming to it? Let me answer my own question - you aren't listed on very many directories, nor do you have many affiliates. Get your site out there! The more you get it out there, the more people will come to your site, and the more hits you will get. The more hits you get, the more people will come... You see the pattern? Get your site out there!!

Quality: --doesn't apply. Your score will be out of 70.--

Updated List: 7/10. Now, before I go on, let me tell you one thing - I can't judge your site in the Updates category like I do other sites. Most guide sites (my GIMP tutorial included) don't need to update often. However, I took off a few points because, yeah, you don't update often (try to go through it at least once or twice a month), but some of those updates are really scanty. Although I see you're trying to butter me up so I'll give you a better review. Nice try, Siddey! But you know it won't work. Or it may. I'm a sucker for being called "best neofriend." :D

Other Problems: Nothing that I can see so far. Just get your site listed in other directories, try to update more often, and fix your grammatical problems!

Overall Score: 59/70. About 85%. Great job, Siddey! There are a few alterations you need to make, but otherwise, everything's great! Go get your 85-89 award from below!
Back to Top

Colours of the Wind

Reviewed on June 19, 2009
Reviewed in Mozilla FireFox
First Glance: 8/10. The background is pretty, but there's really no welcoming banner. If I were just a random visitor to the site, and if I were to just glance at the page, it probably wouldn't draw me in. The "Colours of the Wind" words are on a simple header, which makes me think that the name of the section is "Colours of the Wind." You should make a banner (a colorful banner!) that proclaims the name of your site.

Spelling 5/5. I couldn't find any spelling errors; great job.

Grammar: 3/5. You've been lost in the dreaded Swamp of Commas! Commas are fickle things, aren't they, with all sorts of rules about where to place them and how to use them. Unfortunately, even the most advanced computers can't catch all the comma errors. That sort of thing requires human judgment. Let's continue. The words in italics are your words; the words underneath them in (parentheses) are the corrected words. Let's continue. (Oh, I can't tell you where everything comes from, because that would take up too much space, but you know your own site better than I do; you should know where the sentences come from.)

We have an assortment of graphics for you to choose from like userlookups, blogs, music and more!
(We have an assortment of graphics for you to choose from, like userlookups, blogs, music codes, and more!)

Now there is no more white pixels around Tink!
(Now there are no more white pixels around Tink!)

However if a movie starts with 'the', for example, 'The Lion King', it will be listed as 'Lion King, The'.
(However, if a movie starts with "the," for example, "The Lion King," it will be listed as "Lion King, The.")

Neatness: 7/10. It took me a long time to find your rules. Of course, you only have one rule, but it should be clearly visible. The rule should be before the request info. Requests aren't that important; rules are. That's a big thing - make sure the rules are visible. Otherwise, you have some link borders that you need to get rid of with the simple border="0" code. There is a button in your directories list, Night's Directory, which needs to have the border removed. Your Neomail envelope also has that border around it.

Colors: 9/10. I think you should eyedrop some colors from your background (like the blue from Snow White's dress) to incorporate in your layout, like for the navigation links. That's just my opinion; if you like it the way it is, keep it.

Music: 10/10. Fantastic!! In my opinion, music playing on sites is extremely annoying.

Age of Site: 8/10. You have a good number of hits on your counter, but, alas, your updates from January 21 - February 1 are missing. Whatever could have happened to them? Anyways, when I think of the word "Graphics," I think of icons and banners (this is just me). Your site is named Colors of the Wind Graphics, but there are no icons or banners to be found. Yes, lookups and blogs are there, but I consider lookups to be layouts, and blogs don't really have any category (to me, of course). Where are the icons? The banners? No graphic site is complete without these staples. Of course, if you think your site is fine without them, continue making blogs and layouts. They're nice ^.^

Quality: 6/10. All of the images on the blogs are pixelly, blurry, or stretched. Most of the images on the userlookups are pixelly, blurry, or stretched, save for the Robin Hood and Tinkerbell lookups. I can't check the music codes (because Internet Explorer is going wonky), but everything else seems to have a problem. All of your style one lookups (with one exception - the Peter Pan one) has the little "About Me" box shifted to the right! Don't stretch the graphic to suit the box; make the box go around the graphic! Look at Dark Lights blogs; see how she makes the blog around the image? Don't mess with the images, mess with the blog!

Updated List: 8/10. You're very thorough with your updates, but you skip two to three days at a time. There's also the little matter of not updating until February 2nd - almost two weeks after you first opened your site. Hopefully you just forgot to update, and didn't delete them. There's also a month-long gap between March 13 and April 18. A month-long hiatus? You mention you're going on "vacation," but a month-plus vacation?

Other Problems: Besides the horrible quality of the images on your lookups & blogs, and the weird organization of the page (requests before rules?), everything else seems to be in order.

Overall Score: 64/80. That's an 80% - good job! Just work on upping the quality of the images that you use - that's the biggest score-dropper that I've seen. Remember to update frequently as well. Keep going!
Back to Top

Secret Observer


Reviewed on June 18, 2009
Reviewed in Mozilla FireFox
First Glance: 9/10. The page looks really good - its color scheme really draws you in. The banner is really cool, too, even though it's not made by you. The only thing about the layout that I don't like is that you've put all your SOTM buttons at the top. I know that there are some SOTM that only have on button for you to choose from, but if there are others, you should always choose one that matches your site layout best. The bright-yellow buttons don't match that well, but if they're the only ones they have, it's okay.

Spelling 4/5. You misspelled "affiliates" in this sentence: *After copying the correct form, please choose which contact header are you going to use? Affiliares, or are you Getting Listed??

Grammar: 1/5. You really need to work on your grammar, I'm afraid. Your entire first paragraph is a mess. Let's do it this way: the italics are your words, the plain words in the (parentheses) are what they should say.

Times Square has a major blackout!! What do we do?! A mysterious man comes your way and gives you a one way ticket to a place called Secret Observer. You go on the train, and here you are at Secret Observer.
(Times Square has had a major blackout! What do we do? A mysterious man comes your way, and gives you a one-way ticket to a place called Secret Observer. You step on the subway, and arrive at Secret Observer.)

Salutations! Welcome to Secret Observer, my name is Pip and I will be your observer around here. This is a directory site, that has everything you need from review sites to ranking sites. I hope you enjoy the site! (:
(Salutations! Welcome to Secret Observer. My name is Pip, and I will be your conductor around the site. This is a directory site that has everything you need: from review sites to ranking sites. I hope you enjoy the site!)

5. As of, June 6th, 2009, we will be picky on our affiliates.
(As of June 6th, 2009, we will be picky with our affiliates.)

*After copying the correct form, please choose which contact header are you going to use? Affiliares, or are you Getting Listed??
(*After copying the correct form, please choose which contact header you are going to use. Are you applying to be an affiliate, or are you getting listed?)

As of June 6th, 2009, to be my affie, you must have 88x31 button, and a good site!
(As of June 6th, 2009, if you want to be my affiliate, you must have an 88x31 button and a good site!)

Kill the Lights, is inspired by Kill the Lights, by SRA! It's lights from last layout has been killed and now the darkness hovers all over Times Square.
(Kill the Lights is inspired by Kill the Lights, by SRA! Its lights from the last layout have been killed, and now the darkness hovers over Times Square.)

*Note: never use the words "we got" anywhere. It makes you sound like a hillbilly, or some other hick from the back woods. Try saying "we received." It sounds better.

I could probably find more if I looked through your updates, but I'm letting you off easy.

Neatness: 10/10. Everything seems to have its own place on the page. You even categorize the sites with a key! Asterisks mean the site is your, and a ◄ means that you highly recommend that site. Great job!

Colors: 9/10. The colors all work well together, but there's one thing that bothers me (I'm a little OCD, you see): the colors on your navigation links. You see the little block that's on the left of all of your navigation links? Well, it's gray when you don't hover over it. When you do hover over it, the block barely changes color. You should try changing the hover-over color to black. That would work better, I think. Otherwise, everything looks great!

Music: 10/10. Great!

Age of Site: 7/10. You say your site has been up for two months, yet your counter was started in March (three months ago) and your updates only start on May 1. What happened to the month of April, when your site supposedly started? Where are the April updates? Where is the counter that started in April? Whatever happened to them?

Quality: --Doesn't apply to directories. Your score will be out of 70 points--

Updated List: 6/10. You say your site started two months ago (which would be April), but your updates only start on May 1. What happened to the April updates? There are also several gaps of about... 3-5 days. I mean, my own directory has gaps of weeks, but you seem to keep up with your directory better than I do with mine.

Other Problems: Besides the unexplained April-May gap, everything else seems to be in order. Except your grammar. Fix that.

Overall Score: 46/70. That's a 65%. Not bad! Just fix your grammatical errors, and figure out what happened to your April updates. You have a good site - keep working on it!
Back to Top

Inu-Graphics


Reviewed on June 17, 2009
Reviewed in Mozilla FireFox
First Glance: 5/10. The main picture is nice and mysterious, but it's hard to figure out the name of the site. "Inu-Graphics" is small and nearly impossible to see in the moon. You should make it center-stage in the moon, and a lot bigger, otherwise, who's to know what your site is called? The red also hurts my eyes - why not have a nice, soft blue instead of a glaring red?

Spelling 5/5. I couldn't find any spelling mistakes.

Grammar: 1/5. While you certainly don't have a lot of text on the page, you have plenty of opportunities to make grammatical errors - and you take them. Let's go over them. The words in italics are your words; the words beneath those in (parentheses) are how they should be corrected. Let's begin.

I'm Kagome Chan.
(I'm Kagome-chan.)

My favorite animes are Inuyasha, Naruto, FMA, and Bleach.^_^I have to give some credit to my two neofriends Maya and Kona.
(My favorite animes are InuYasha, Naruto, FullMetal Alchemist, and Bleach. ^_^ I have to give some credit to my two neofriends, Maya and Kona.)

This graphics site wouldn't be happening with out them. So thanks to Kona and Maya for helping me with my graphics site.
(This graphics site wouldn't have happened without them. So thanks, Kona and Maya, for helping me with my graphics site.)

Now if your ever on the wall of shame you're will be found in a whole lot of trouble with The Neopets Team. And you even might be put on the Anime protecton And if you ever need help with graphics Neomail me
(Now, if you're ever on the Wall of Shame, you'll be in a lot of trouble with The Neopets Team. You might even be put on the Anime Protection List! If you ever need help with graphics, Neomail me.)

The main problem that you have is that you aren't putting spaces between the punctuation and the beginning of the next sentence. This leads to things looking very ugly, and it makes things hard to read (especially on a blinding-red layout).

Neatness: 4/10. You have no navigation whatsoever on the pages (navigation is important; it helps people get around), and having the text areas to the right of the icons makes things confusing. Here, you can use this code for your icons (it's a table code; replace my words with your own. Repeat the code for every three icons):
Be sure to put your images in the right place, and the text areas in the right place. Only delete the words. Leave all the other codings in place. This will help organize your icons better. If you want another row of tables, simply copy the code again and put your images in again. You can only do three icons per table code. You can also use this code for your link-back buttons.

Your updated list is also backwards; you should have the newest updates at the top, and the oldest updates at the bottom. That way, people don't have to scroll continuously to figure out what's new with your site.

You need your link-back buttons up before you have your reviews!! Reviews can be put in the same box as the affiliates; you can put them underneath the affiliates. Simply delete the box containing the reviews now, and move them under the affies, with the heading "Reviews," of course.

Colors: 2/10. The red is very, very hard on the eyes. You have a pretty blue background, and a pretty shades-of-blue image, so why in Neopia do you have red in your layout at all? It should be blue - a dark blue, with the writing white. That would look much better (and would be much easier on your visitors!). The name of the site blends in to the moon, so it looks like it's hardly there at all. Make is a strong color - something that will stand out on the blue/white of the moon, but won't hurt eyes.

Music: 10/10. Great! Music on petpages (in my opinion) is very annoying.

Age of Site: 4/10. There is no counter, and there's not even a note saying which day you started the site on! You don't have that many graphics (and some of those graphics are just wallpapers you found on Google!), but you have a lot of affiliates. It's good that you're advertising your site, but you need to get listed on some directories as well! The more you put your site out there, the more visitors will come. And you need a counter! Search "Boingdragon Counters" on Google, & you'll find a link to a site that has counters for your petpage. A counter counts how many people visit your petpage (make sure you put the date you started the counter next to the counter!).

Quality: 3/10. One of the icons (the Edward Elric one) is just a wallpaper that you shrunk down to almost-icon size, and there's another icon that's more pixelly than it needs to be. The "Something has Happened!" link-back buttons have pixelly images, and are too big for the box they are contained in. Some of the banners are pixelly (pixelly = bad), and the credit that you've put on them is TOO BIG. You can put your name in the lower-right-hand corner, if you wish, but in a nice pixel font, size ten, and make it black. Honestly, I don't think you should be too worried with people stealing your banners. They're not all that good. (Harsh, but honest. I'm sorry, but honesty is my policy.)

You should really just get rid of the "Something has Happened" banners, because they won't do anything for you. They're too pixelly, and the one about the InuYasha "human" avatar doesn't make any sense at all!

There's something that's bugging me, too. If you're so good at the icons, why can't you transfer the same thing over to the banners? The icons are amazing, but the banners, to be completely honest, look like a two-year-old did them. Now, if you were so accomplished with the icons, you can do the same thing with the banners. The banners are just really, really big icons. I'm really starting to wonder whether you just found the icons on Google, too.

If you can't make the graphics yourself (with brushes, different fonts, & such), then don't steal wallpapers from search engines & claim them as "banners." Go find a nice, free program (I like GIMP; I even have a tutorial for it), download it, & use that to make your images! Don't infringe on copyrights!

Updated List: 5/10. Okay. You have some updates - but they're going in the WRONG DIRECTION! Updates should run from newest to oldest, not from oldest to newest! The newest updates are on the top; that makes people see that you're still ALIVE, and you're UPDATING the site with NEW THINGS. If they see a REALLY OLD date at the top of the site's updates, they're going to think you haven't updated since that day and won't come back.

Other Problems: Besides the banners-that-are-not-banners, the fishy icons, the blinding-red background, the main header-banner, and the HUGE link-back "SHH" buttons, the only other thing that I can think of is organizing your text areas.

Overall Score: 39/80. That's a 47%. Really, for your first graphics site, that's not a bad score at all. There are a lot of things that you need to fix, I'm not going to lie to you. But graphic sites take a lot of time and hard work. Mine has been up for almost a year, and I'm still not satisfied with it. I'm constantly making changes (changing the layout, updating the page, adding new graphics, collecting affies & reviewers, etc.) and trying to improve it. You have some potential - your InuYasha icons are really good. You just need to apply that to everything else in your site. Keep going - you have a long road ahead of you, & it's mostly uphill. But if you keep working at it, you'll come out on top. Keep going!

While you're at it, check this site out:
It'll help you a LOT!
Back to Top

Connie's Fake Avs

Reviewed on June 16, 2009
Reviewed in Internet Explorer
First Glance: 7/10. It's a nice layout (not done by you, but it's nice). There's just one thing missing - what happened to the background? The white of the background makes the page look plain, boring, and dull. While the glitter heading takes the attention slightly away from the white, it's still not enough. Get a nice blue background. That'll match better, and will make the page look much prettier.

Spelling 1/5. I caught a lot of spelling mistakes. First of all, "wich," (correction: which), which is in your introductory paragraph. In the second paragraph, "request," (correction: requests) is missing the 's' that makes it plural. In your rules section, "atleast" (correction: at least) has been combined into one word. In your FAQ, the third question, "tem" (correction: them). Underneath the Gallery Avatar section, "annonymus" (correction: anonymous) is misspelled. Underneath the Final Word section, you say "I haven't seens them" (correction: I haven't seen them). In the Link Me section, you use the horrible chatspeak term "u" (correction: you). Don't use chatspeak! If you're not sure how to spell a word, use an online dictionary.

Grammar: 1/5. There are way too many grammatical mistakes for me to put in this review, I'm afraid. The one that I saw most often was that you forgot a word, or you didn't capitalize the word "I." Try copying-and-pasting your coding into Microsoft Word or another program with a spellchecker placed in it. The program will also check your grammar.

Neatness: 7/10. I think you should put your FAQ section at the end of your page, before your affiliates. The misc. section could also go at the end. If people have to scroll a lot (if they don't like using the navigation bar for some weird reason) just to get to your first graphic, that's not a good sign. Try rearranging the page a little bit.

Colors: 8/10. The blues match (of course they do; the person who made your layout has a great sense of color coordination), but there's a lot of white. What did you do with the background? Try putting a light blue as the background - or replacing the original background!

Music: 10/10. No music! Yay! That's great! Usually people who use Internet Explorer a lot like to put music on their pages - against the wishes of most of Neopia. Great job on keeping your page music-free!

Age of Site: 5/10. You have no "Site Started" date anywhere on your page. That makes it hard to judge when you started your site, so I can't judge accurately on the amount of graphics you have. You have very few updates (when you add a new avatar, you should update!), and only three reviews. You aren't listed on any directories (that I can see). The more you get your site out there, the more visitors you'll have!

Quality: 8/10. The avatars are really nice, but they all have the same basic animation. Try mixing things up a bit! Variety is the spice of life! Otherwise, they're very nice!

Updated List: 2/10. You've been open for at least seven months (December - June), and you only have *counts* three updates. What happened to the other ones? Updates tell visitors (and reviewers) what you are doing with your site. When did you add all those new avatars? Update the site!

Other Problems: The only real problems (that I can see) are your spelling and grammar mistakes, and the scanty updates. Fix those, and you'll be on your way to a fantastic site!

Overall Score: 49/80. That's a 61%. Not bad; it's better than a 50%! Keep working on your site; you have great potential. You just have to tap into it.
Back to Top
If you earned an award, see below to collect it!

Awards

There are several awards that you can recieve - 85-89, 90-95, 96-99, & 100%. Depending on your review score, you can get one of these rewards. HOWEVER, be warned: if you take an award and your name isn't on this list, you will be reported for stealing. NO. STEALING. AWARDS.

85-89:
Winners:
Amy's Button Basket
Ace
The Faerie Fountain
Microsoft Paint Guide
Pixelburgh, PA
Kandy Kanes
Ready, Set, Graphics
Starry_Mimi's Dailies
Nyponte's Adoptables
Graphic Sites: A Complete Guide

90-95
Winners:
Elements
Grantauy's All-In-One Guide
Circus
Cotton Candy Premades
Sarah's Neopoint Guide
Superfly CSS
Anime Ike
Photo Finish Designs
Mel's Customs
2 Stars Graphics
Blinking Lookups
Soroptomist Directory
Precious Dreams
Pitty's Glitters

96-99:
Winners:
Face Paint
Creating a Petpage
Otaku Works
Spellbound
Siddey's String
Pixelfreak
Pixeldust
Jemz's Petpages
The Faerie Compass
Good and Broken Graphics
Twisted Shrooms
Disney Animations & More
Dark Light Graphics

100:
Winners:
None! Try for it!

Back to Top




NEOPETS, characters, logos, names and all related indicia
are trademarks of Neopets, Inc., © 1999-2009.
® denotes Reg. US Pat. & TM Office. All rights reserved.

PRIVACY POLICY | Safety Tips | Contact Us | About Us | Press Kit
Use of this site signifies your acceptance of the Terms and Conditions