Divine Reviews
Updates
9/02 I am starting a graphics site called Divine Graphics.My Guild
This guild is a very succesful guild. Im not going to review it as it is my guild. But here is the link in case you have nothing else. ☆Welcome
Hello and welcome to m_c_r_girl_4_life's guild rating page. I will start by having a simple top guilds list. When I have that I will introduce catogaries eg. HP, NR, Fashion, Anime etc. I will have a link to each guild and a link to the leaders profile. There will be a 5 star rating on it and a little review. I may chat to some members to see what they think of the guild. So what do you think. If you want your guild to be reviewed, read below for the T&Cs.T&Cs
So you want your guild reviewed, well of course I'll review it if you are prepared to have it critised. I am not saying I will say your guild is rubbish just like that, but if I think it could be better I will say. Here are my rules.
1. Do NOT complain about my reviews thats just plain mean, if you HAVE read the top bit you will understand.
2. If your guild is changed in anyway or you want me to re-review it it is your responsibility to neomail me. I am happy to re-review any guild as longs as it has changed since the last time.
3. LEADERS ONLY. I do not want members to submit guilds. Sorry.
4. I will make a button. If you want to advertise my page in your guild or on your userlookup please do.
5. Please do not take my comments to heart. I do not know you so please don't get upset.
Please read below to find out how to submit your guild.
How to submit
Please make sure you have read all of the above before you read this.Fill out the following form and neomail it to me.
Guild Name:
Link:
Theme:
Discription:(Just put a little history)
After you have filled out the form neomail it to me and I will do the rest.
Neomail me
Click Here to neomail meThe Guilds
Gateway to Glimmer
Name and Link: Gateway to GlimmerTheme: Spyro
Leader: Kyromin
Founded: 12/23/2007
Review Date: 1/12/2008
Stars: ☆☆☆
Review: Well I like this guild. It has an ok layout, It has most of the average things a guild has. It hasnt really thought very much about having orginal things, apart from of course the theme. It is quite new and hasn't really kicked off yet. I personally would not join simply because I prefer other themes. But, any Spyro lover would get something out of this guild. The webbie on the other hand, is not as good as the guild itself. I think it has all the right info, but the layout really does let it down. All in all an OK guild with Ok graphics.
The Donators Guild '08
Name and Link: The Donators Guild '08Theme: Neopet Related/Donating
Leader: ili_seven_ili
Founded: 01/03/2008
Review Date: 1/12/2008
Stars: ☆☆☆
Review: Well it has a large sum of np in the bank. It has made a good start with refering. The coding is great, BUT the graphics let the guild down. :(. This is because the image quality is poor and the color scheme (grey background) isn't the greatest either. I think this guild has the potential to be a massive millionaires guild. But at the moment I suggest that you get a new layout or make the image quality better(I know its hard :()
The Elven Kingdoms of Middle-earth
Name and Link The Elven Kingdoms of Middle-earthTheme: Lord of the Rings and the elves
Leader: arewen_undomiel_13
Founded: 04/22/2003
Review Date: 1/12/2008
Stars ☆☆
Review: Well this guild would be given three stars, but it is very old so that, in my opinion, removes a star. The layout is ok but you cannot read the bit where it says members, page views etc. This isn't great either. BUT on a positive note the members look pretty active as they have posted a lot of posts. Looking at the webbie you can see there was an active guild there, but it may of died down a bit. I think this guild has good potential BUT I think you should just make a new guild and start again as it is so old, members who may want to join may be put off by the guilds age.
Neopets of the Rainbow
This guild has CLOSED. Please tell me if your guild closes. Take this as an example of what NOT to do.☽Xwee☆Forest☽
Name and Link: ☽Xwee☆Forest☽Theme: FanatsyNeopets RGP
Leader: Reborn_Phoenix
Review Date: 1/12/2008
Founded:11/11/2007
Stars: ☆☆☆
Review: Well this guild has a nice theme and a nice layout. But it is only nice. It not spectacular. There aren't many pages, you have a webbie though. They are all average things you find in a guild. The webbie, on the other hand is very good. Nice layout, Great Contents, I don't know why but it really caught my eye.
~*Paint Brushes or What*~
Name and Link: ~*Paint Brushes or What~*PRIVATE
Theme: Paint Brushes
Leader: lucy_star_catcher
Review Date: 1/13/2008
Founded: 07/27/2007
Stars: ☆☆☆
Review: This guild is good, in the respect that its popular. But the content and the quality really isn't all that great. The guild has a premade layout, as very well used one infact,it has a custom layout on the webbie, but it really isn't all that great. It has all the usual things you would typically find in a guild. It states that it has two webbies. The music is out of date. But on a positive note the guild has done really well refering members. They also have a very nice meet the council page and they had a very nice christmas quest page.
Fire Faerie's hot spot
Name and Link: Fire Faerie's hot spotTheme: Fire Faerie
Leader: neotrainertyler
Review Date: 1/16/2008
Founded: 01/15/2008
Stars: ☆
Review: Well I think this guild is not as good as it could be. I have only given it 1 star because I personally do not like the layout and there aren't many members. On a more positive note It is only new. My advice is start again and get a co-owner
Potter's Legacy
Name and Link: Potter's LegacyTheme: Harry Potter
Leader:Saphira01983
Review Date: 1/16/2008
Founded: 01/06/2008
Stars: ☆☆☆☆
Review: This guild is very good, it is well established. There are plenty of active members. It has a lovely layout and I nice stack of page views. I think you should keep this guild going as it really iany Hs great. It's not that popular yet, but I have no doubt it should be soon. I recommend this for any Harry Potter fan. My only critisism is that the layout covers up all the stats. :(
To Review
Sorry I couldn't do your review straight away I will do it asap.