Trophies are awarded based on the following criteria:

1. Scoretacular - Beat or match AAA's score on the launch day of all 30 games, as well as all four Double Dare challenges.
2. The Ultimate Prize - Beat or match AAA's score on the launch day of all the games.
3. Uberiffic - Beat or match all of Abigail's scores or a combination of AAA's and Abigail's scores on the launch day of every game.
4. Megasuperb - Beat or match AAA's scores for all of the games by the end of Daily Dare.
5. Spifftastic - Beat or match all of Abigail's scores or a combination of AAA's and Abigail's scores for all of the games by the end of Daily Dare.